Hangtown Grill
(512) 347-1039
701 S Capital Of Texas Hwy
Austin, TX 78746

Aljons Pizza & Italian Restaurant
(512) 447-2306
1945 E. Oltorf Street
Austin, TX 78741

Mangia Chicago Stuffed Pizza
(512) 478-6600
2401 Lake Austin Boulevard
Austin
, TX 78703
Mangia Chicago Stuffed Pizza
(512) 302-5200
3500 Guadalupe Street
Austin, TX 78705
Mangia Chicago Stuffed Pizza
(512) 349-2126
8012 Mesa Drive
Austin, TX 78757
Saccone's Pizza
and Subs

(512) 259-1882
2701-A N. Bell Boulevard
Cedar Park, TX 78613
see our menu
Reale's Pizzeria
(512) 335-5115
13450 N. Highway 183, Suite 230
Austin, TX 78750
 


Winners and losers in the Pizza Wars

I must tell you that I'm originally from the Mecca of great Sicilian pizza, New Haven, Connecticut. So I'm a bit biased. But I've also raised two teen-agers, so I've been exposed to every manner of pizza that some able-bodied soul can schlep to my front door. That being said, it's time for our annual assessment of the best and worst of Austin pizza. We like to call it Pizza Wars.

Dwelling at the bottom of the pizza food chain is Domino's. You could tear open a loaf of unleavened bread and splatter some sauce on it and it exceeds what Domino's puts out. Only slightly better than Domino's is Double Dave's. Cute name, lousy crust. Terrible pizza. Moving up a tad, we come to Mr. Gatti''s and Papa John's. These are at least somewhat edible, though vastly overrated. And they remain edible for at least fifteen minutes after exiting the oven, something that the lowest-rated pizzas cannot claim.

Yet another step up, in my humble opinion, is Pizza Hut. Their meat lover's pizza is really not bad for a chain. And those baby pan pizzas at Little Caesar's can be somewhat tasty as well. And check out the veggie pizza at the Hangtown Grills.

Several more steps up the ladder are locally operated spots like Chicago-style Mangia’s. I'm not a huge fan of deep dish but Mangia's the best of the local fare. I'd put them considerably ahead of Conan's, the other major deep dish player. Also on that higher rung is a venerable South Austin pizza emporium, Aljon's at 1945 East Oltorf. Love the pepperoni at Aljon's.

Which brings us to the top of the food chain. Light years removed from bottom feeders like Domino's are Reale's at 13450 research, Saccone's with locations on 183 and in Leander, and Brick Oven with locations on Red River, Jollyville and Lakeline. All three are excellent. Saccone's probably comes the closest to duplicating my favorite New Jersey/Connecticut pizza. Brick Oven has a sensational vegetarian pizza with a firmer crust, and Reale's brings more of an Upper New York State style. Their Italian sausage is quite good.

Who's the best? Saccone's by about the size of a thin slice of pepperoni. But all three pass the overnight test, probably the most critical benchmark for pizza lovers. That is, you can stick the leftovers in the fridge, open the box the next morning, and wolf down a slice without benefit of reheating. And it's still good. Try doing that with Double Dave's!

Top of page

 

 

©2000 diningoutwithrobbalon.com
Would you like to advertise on diningoutwithrobbalon.com?

Site designed by